International tax reporting has developed a habit of accumulating new requirements. Once introduced, they rarely disappear, even when subsequent measures cover much of the same ground.
The UK’s new International Controlled Transactions Schedule (ICTS), applying from 2027, is the latest addition. HMRC expects it to raise an additional £350 million annually by 2030–31, while estimating business compliance costs of just £6 million initially and £2 million a year thereafter. As we’ll see, those estimates look remarkably optimistic.
How much information do tax authorities already have?
Consider the international tax reporting requirements introduced over the last decade.
Multinational businesses already prepare transfer pricing master files and local files, documenting their operations, financing, related-party transactions and pricing methodologies. Country-by-country reporting provides information about profits, employees and taxes across jurisdictions. Pillar Two has added the GloBE Information Return and its considerable supporting calculations.
Within the EU, there is public country-by-country reporting and mandatory disclosure under DAC6, including arrangements involving certain transfer pricing risks. In the UK, we have separate mandatory disclosure regimes, notification of uncertain tax treatments and numerous disclosures within corporation tax returns. Individual countries impose further transactional reporting requirements.
Not all of these apply to every business, nor is all the information routinely submitted. Nevertheless, we are hardly short of information being prepared and disclosed.
HMRC argues that existing transfer pricing documentation is unsuitable for automated risk assessment. Master and local files are primarily narrative documents, while country-by-country reports are relatively high-level. ICTS will instead provide standardised information about controlled transactions, pricing methods and financial results.
Clearly, transfer pricing enquiries are notoriously lengthy and expensive, and better-targeted enquiries would benefit HMRC and taxpayers alike.
However, much of the information will already exist within businesses’ accounting records and transfer pricing documentation. ICTS is therefore partly about making information easier for HMRC to use, rather than obtaining information which businesses have never previously been required to assemble.
That seems a reasonable basis for considering whether some of the existing requirements could be reduced.
Other countries are already looking at duplication
The UK is not pioneering annual transfer pricing reporting. Australia has its International Dealings Schedule, Poland has TPR reporting, while France and Belgium have similar requirements.
Australia provides a useful example of how overlapping obligations can be managed. Qualifying businesses submitting Part A of their transfer pricing local file with their tax return need not complete corresponding disclosures in questions 2–17 of the International Dealings Schedule.
The European Commission is also looking at simplifying reporting requirements. Its June 2026 proposals include reducing certain DAC6 disclosures and combining notifications relating to country-by-country reporting and Pillar Two. The Commission estimates that the latter change alone could save businesses more than €260 million annually.
Neither approach involves abandoning transparency. Both recognise that collecting the same information repeatedly serves little purpose.
HMRC has suggested that information reported through ICTS might be excluded from local file requirements. I hope this is taken forward, although the explanatory memorandum accompanying the regulations expressly states that ICTS does not replace any previous policy.
£80 to set up, £27 a year thereafter
Spread across the approximately 75,000 potentially affected businesses, HMRC’s estimates work out at £80 in initial costs and £27 annually. These are averages across that population, not estimates per actual filing, but they still seem remarkably modest.
The June draft of ICTS envisages around a dozen reporting fields for each grouping of non-financial controlled transactions, potentially including additional details for up to ten significant counterparties. Financing arrangements have their own reporting requirements.
Consider a multinational with several UK companies and numerous overseas counterparties. Transaction data may sit in different accounting systems, financing arrangements in treasury software and pricing methodologies in transfer pricing documentation. Reconciling these, particularly where year-end adjustments are involved, could require changes to existing systems and additional work across tax, finance and treasury teams.
There is also some precedent for scepticism about HMRC’s estimates. In February 2025, the National Audit Office concluded that HMRC’s estimate of the administrative cost of the tax system to businesses was understated, noting that research into compliance time had, in most cases, not been updated since 2015. The Public Accounts Committee has separately identified substantial taxpayer transition costs omitted from earlier Making Tax Digital assessments.
This does not establish that HMRC’s ICTS estimates are wrong, but it would be interesting to see the assumptions underlying them.
Will it actually raise revenue?
There is some empirical evidence that suggest greater transparency may improve tax compliance[1]. The difficulty is establishing how much additional benefit each successive reporting obligation produces.
HMRC’s evaluation of the notification of uncertain tax treatment regime illustrates the distinction. By March 2025, notifications covered more than £900 million of uncertain tax positions, including matters previously unknown to HMRC. However, HMRC acknowledged that it was too early to estimate the tax protected.
Identifying a potentially uncertain tax position is not the same as collecting additional tax.
The £350 million forecast for ICTS may prove accurate. It is based on anticipated improvements in compliance and enforcement, rather than changes to the underlying transfer pricing rules. Its success should therefore be assessed by reference to the additional revenue actually collected, the costs imposed on businesses and whether HMRC’s enquiries become more effective.
I would be particularly interested in the last point. Fewer lengthy transfer pricing enquiries resulting in little or no adjustment would be a worthwhile achievement.
A case for fewer, better reporting requirements
The concern is not that ICTS serves no purpose. It is that international tax reporting requirements continue to accumulate without much corresponding effort to rationalise what already exists.
I would favour a requirement that every new reporting measure is accompanied by a review of what information is already collected, how it could be reused and whether existing obligations can be simplified or removed.
Not every new return needs to replace an old one. But surely the objective should be better tax compliance, rather than simply more tax reporting.
Businesses are expected to substantiate their tax positions with detailed evidence and calculations. It seems reasonable to expect similar rigour in demonstrating the benefits and costs of another reporting obligation.
[1] Research published in the Journal of Accounting Research in 2020 found that businesses affected by confidential country-by-country reporting experienced an increase of approximately 1–2 percentage points in their consolidated accounting effective tax rates, alongside some evidence of reduced income shifting.